A COMPARISON OF THE ADDITIONAL PROTOCOLS OF THE FIVE NUCLEAR WEAPON STATES AND THE ENSUING SAFEGUARDS BENEFITS TO INTERNATIONAL NONPROLIFERATION EFFORTS

With the 6 January 2009 entry into force of the Additional Protocol by the United States of America, all five declared Nuclear Weapon States that are part of the Nonproliferation Treaty have signed, ratified, and put into force the Additional Protocol. This paper makes a comparison of the strengths and weaknesses of the five Additional Protocols in force by the five Nuclear Weapon States with respect to the benefits to international nonproliferation aims. This paper also documents the added safeguards burden to the five declared Nuclear Weapon States that these Additional Protocols put on the states with respect to access to their civilian nuclear programs and the hosting of complementary access activities as part of the Additional Protocol.